Will there be songs in the movies?

I wonder who are we going to hear it from... Gildor, Arwen... Aragorn?

I'd say we'll hear Arwen singing it in Rivendell.

Liv Tyler singing? never heard her, but with what they're doing to Arwen, i'm worried...

and (in the book, at least) Sam "cries" Elbereth Gilthoniel in Cirith Ungol when Frodo's fallen - they'd better leave that in.

Shan - there is a similar expression in English, but i can't remember its exact wording.

aryne *

There's been stuff going on about mastering the voices of the Elves... To make them Elf-like.

I think this goes for Arwen and as well as others...

How will they master them?
Adding echo? :lol:

:lol:

Master of Ceremony!

Ooh, in the "Dune" movie (that's frequently cited as what PJ should avoid for LotR! ) remember they did those weird echo voices when the Bene Gesserit did their version of the Jedi Mind Trick? That was annoying.

Just think of Xenarwen echoing :lol:

That movie version of the BG Voice technique was terrible. Anything to that effect should not be present, in any movie.

The above mentioned quote in French, translated later in English, was spoken long ago in Aramaic, an ancient Hebrew dialect.

"And they took offence at him. But Jesus said to them, 'Only in his hometown and in his own house is a prophet without honor.' And he did not do many miracles there because of their lack of faith."
--Matthew 13:57-58

Thanx Gilthalion for the precision

Just happened to know that one!