12-18-2007, 05:05 AM | #121 | ||||
Lady of the Ulairi
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Minas Morgul
Posts: 2,783
|
Ohh… another great old thread- my first one, indeed. I confess I haven’t re-read it now, partly because it is so long, but partly on purpose: to have a fresh view of the matter.
I think you are right, CAB (and Olmer), that the people MOST interested in Isildur’s death, VITALLY interested even, were those who had the other rings of power: Elrond, Galadriel, Cirdan, the 9 nazgul, maybe also the Dwarf-lords (though the latter were never really governed by the One – so I leave them out). It is just totally unrealistic to think that they would have waited idly for a new Ringlord to emerge and enslave them. On one hand, we have the ambush on the East bank – led by “the grim servants of Barad-Dur(UT)”. Now can we be sure that there wasn’t a single Ringwraith among them? We know that some/most/all (??) of the nazgul fled East after the Fall of Barad-Dur - but in two years they might have returned. Alternatively, as we are never told about the nazgul during the fights of the Last Alliance, probably some have always been away from Mordor – preparing and leading reinforcements from the subject lands or prowling on the Alliance’s communication lines. Anyway, we are told that the orcs were drawn to the Ring – and if there were Ringwraiths in Mirkwood it gets so much easier to explain how they spotted the Ring. Also it might explain why the invisible Isildur chose to swim over (a rather perilous thing to attempt, specially at night) and not to run upstream or downstream or into the trees and hide. On the other hand, we have an ambush on the West bank – because Isildur was slain near the West bank: his body was found there by Saruman, and Gollum found the Ring by the west bank, as he lived on the west bank near the Gladden river (see here: http://www.ititches.com/middleearth/index.html) And this ambush is interesting. Think about it: west bank, right midway between Rivendell and Lorien, two years after the victory. Was it likely to find orcs there? Not at all likely, if you ask me, next to impossible even. Any orc would have long ago moved upriver a bit, crossed to the East bank at the “old Ford” and joined the Mirkwood company – or gone to hide in the caves of the Misty mountains. Much more likely was to find Elves on the west bank- namely Elrond and Galadriel and some of their people. Quote:
I agree with CAB. The first part- the fighting on the East bank- seems OK: happened as reported. It had a few surviving witnesses and the area was later examined not only by the Elves, but also by Men from surrounding areas and likely by Valandil’s mannish entourage from Rivendell. As for the Palantiri, (see my thread here: http://www.entmoot.com/showthread.ph...401#post598401) it is unknown if Isildur was followed via the Seeing Stones or not, but the Elves had to expect it – so they couldn’t have ambushed the 200-strong Dunedain party in plain daylight themselves and hope to get away with it. But… they likely knew about the big orc force on the other bank and chose NOT to warn Isildur. Let us go further. Isildur swam across the river. But did the Ring abandon Isildur or was he slain with the Ring on? If he was slain by Calaquendi Elves (like Galadriel, or Glorfindel, or Gildor and Co) or ring-wielders (like Elrond) then he might have been slain while invisible to mortal eyes, still wearing the Ring. But the Ring was later found separately from Isildur’s body, so those who slew him had to take off the Ring from his finger and throw it into the river. It is unlikely: very strange hiding place – so near the bank. Why not damp it in the middle of the river or better still throw it into the Sea (Orodruin being dormant)? So, I believe this part is also correct: the Ring abandoned Isildur while he was approaching the west bank. Why did the Ring choose this exact moment to slip off? Did it want to get lost in the River? Unlikely, and note that it didn’t slip in the middle of the river, but by the bank. The Ring had no senses of its own, IMO, it only processed the feelings of its wielder (for the explanations see here: http://www.entmoot.com/showthread.ph...400#post598400 ). It must have slipped because Isildur saw someone/something awaiting him on the West bank – but what? Orcs? But how could Isildur, an inexperienced Ring-wielder, see the concealed orcs at night, while he was still in the hazy World of Shadow? See this quote about Sam: Quote:
Quote:
Did the Elves start shooting when Isildur were still invisible? Maybe yes, maybe not, but the Calaquendi must have identified the Wannabe Ringlord without doubt. Likely they were waiting for the man to get out of the water. And they had to kill him – because otherwise he would have done everything to retrieve the Ring, as he knew exactly where he lost it. Quote:
|
||||
12-18-2007, 06:43 PM | #122 | ||||
Elven Warrior
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 306
|
Quote:
Quote:
I get the impression that Isildur was on the run for quite awhile after fleeing from the battle. Supposedly he first "ran like a stag from the hounds" and then "halted, to make sure that he was not pursued" and "then he went on more warily". Seems reasonable, pretty much what anyone in the same position would do, I think. I also think that what pretty much anyone (including Isildur) would do is take off the Ring after the post sprint pause. Here's why. First, the sprint probably would have continued if he thought that Orcs were near behind him. Second, the Ring was still extremely hot at this time, burning him. I know that fear can overcome pain for a while, but not forever. Once the initial rush wore off, the burning would probably be unbearable. Quote:
Quote:
|
||||
12-19-2007, 01:23 AM | #123 | |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: LI-woods, NY
Posts: 653
|
It was fun to re-read the whole thread, it refreshed my memory and made me realise of being mistaken about some points.
CAB, I like your observation on Isildur's escape, seems he has had another purpose than just to run away and hide, because as invisible you can walk through the wood for miles being unnoticeable. But plunging into a swirling and swift river with a "little hope to gain the other shore"(UT) is looking like having a death wish. Besides, swimming in the water is the most blatant way to reveal yourself even being invisible. I agree with you that Isildur was not keeping the Ring on his finger, since he "dread the pain of touching it"(UT) So he would put on the Ring only in an extreme situation, which might has happened twice: on the battlefield and when he was swimming in the river. If in the first instance I agree with Gordis on a possible presence of a lesser Ringwraith among the attackers, then the second is totally open to a speculation. Quote:
__________________
Uruk-hai, or the journey to there. Last edited by Olmer : 12-19-2007 at 06:48 PM. |
|
12-19-2007, 04:24 AM | #124 | |
Elven Warrior
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 306
|
Quote:
|
|
12-19-2007, 09:22 AM | #125 |
High King at Annuminas Administrator
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Wyoming - USA
Posts: 10,752
|
Grrrrr... I loaned out my copy of UT 6 months ago, and still haven't got it back, so pardon me if I can't refer to what is written there.
As for swimming the Gladden - why, Olmer, do you say that he had 'little hope to gain the other shore'? And you have it in quotes - was that in the UT account? I don't remember it, but I do remember from the 'Description of Numenor' that the Numenoreans excelled at swimming. Besides - he apparently made it all the way, until he unfortunately met a winged messenger at the other side (of whose sending, we seem to be at odds). Also Olmer - I don't think the Ring was STILL so hot. It was when he wrote the scroll which Gandalf recounted to Frodo. But it was now going on two years since he had taken it from Sauron's finger. He also says there, 'even as I write it is cooled...' Gordis - the west bank may have been between Lorien and Rivendell, but there were a LOT of miles between the two, as well as a great mountain range. That area was pretty clearly wilderness, and we shouldn't assume it was settled & 'safe' just because it lay in between those two lands. As for Orc archers being stationed there as the UT account says, they may have just been sent there - maybe as soon as the Orcs spotted Isildur's convoy. They could have sent some lads across the way in a hidden boat or two, knowing that they would attack from the east, so that they might pick up escapees who might make it across the river, if any escaped that way. I don't think there's a need to suppose that this detachment of Orc archers had been sitting there for 10 years or so. As for the 'dread the pain of touching it'- which you quote from the UT account, why do you discard so much of what that account says, but keep that piece? Are you folks just picking and choosing parts that support an alternate theory, and tossing out parts that oppose it?
__________________
My Fanfic: Letters of Firiel Tales of Nolduryon Visitors Come to Court Ñ á ë ?* ó ú é ä ï ö Ö ñ É Þ ð ß ® ™ [Xurl=Xhttp://entmoot.tolkientrail.com/showthread.php?s=&postid=ABCXYZ#postABCXYZ]text[/Xurl] Splitting Threads is SUCH Hard Work!! |
12-19-2007, 11:59 AM | #126 |
Lady of the Ulairi
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Minas Morgul
Posts: 2,783
|
CAB - I see your reasons to think that Isildur took off the Ring before getting into the water. But taking it off, he would most likely put it into that special locker he had with him and which Saruman later recovered. No way could the Ring slip out of that one. So your argument implies either:
1. that the killers of Isildur took the Ring out of the locker and threw it into the river, and then dumped Isildur's body (with Elendilmir, precious locker etc.) into the river separately. That is impossible if the attackers were Orcs, very unlikely with Elves. 2. or that Isildur, while swimming, took the Ring out of the locker and attempted to put it on his finger when it slipped off by its own volition. 3. or that isildur, while swimming, took the ring out of the locker and deliberately let it sink - not to give it to those waiting for him on the west bank (that was Olmer's idea early in this thread) |
12-19-2007, 01:18 PM | #127 | ||||
Lady of the Ulairi
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Minas Morgul
Posts: 2,783
|
Val, I don't think any of us are deliberately disregarding information from UT or LOTR.
Here is the quote Olmer mentioned: "He was a man of strength and endurance that few even of the Dúnedain of that age could equal, but he had little hope to gain the other shore." (I guess because the river was swift here and he was vert tired already) When Isildur got the Ring it was "hot as a glede", then it was gradually cooling but still painful to wear. Quote:
On the other hand, the nazgul (if present)had to be apprehensive of the one who had the ring, so it made sense that even if all the nine were there nearby, driving the orcs onwards, they themselves would stay away: Quote:
I was unable to find out what the phase of the Moon was - a pity, but it looks like the sky was overcast anyway. Note that if the night were very dark, Isildur wearing the ring might see better than a mortal - the case of Sam in Shelob's lair. Maybe Isildur left the ring on, while he swam, because it is said: "Isildur turned west, and drawing up the Ring that hung in a wallet from a fine chain about his neck, he set it upon his finger with a cry of pain, and was never seen again by any eye upon Middle-earth." And that's how Isildur lost his ring according to UT Quote:
And the last sentence might be especially interesting for you, Val. Quote:
Last edited by Gordis : 12-19-2007 at 01:25 PM. |
||||
12-19-2007, 02:29 PM | #128 |
High King at Annuminas Administrator
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Wyoming - USA
Posts: 10,752
|
Gordis - the main thing some of you may be disregarding is the 'who shot whom' - but that's very important, of course.
I still think the Ring had cooled (since Isildur had written in the scroll describing it that it cooled - as recounted at the Council of Elrond). Perhaps it was painful to Isildur for some other reason. As to the very last - conflicting information, or at least when it says he is the 'last' - it may mean the last to be recognized as King of both Arnor and Gondor - while not excluding the possibility of a King of Arnor still being considered "High King" over both. I believe Appendix A is clear that the Kings of Arnor were considered High Kings all the way through Earendur - up to the time of Arnor's Division. Now... will no one but me dispute for the honor and goodness of the Elves? No "true believers" left out there? BTW - my comment about this being a view of the Elves that makes them seem more 'perilous' was refering to comments by the Professor himself. At least that's how I THINK he put it. He makes it plain that it isn't an easy thing for Men to just go off frolicking with Elves - as many people seem to want to perceive things. So THAT part of it, I was just implying, does lend some credence to this theory. But... we cannot fully explore it unless someone argues the reverse, can we?
__________________
My Fanfic: Letters of Firiel Tales of Nolduryon Visitors Come to Court Ñ á ë ?* ó ú é ä ï ö Ö ñ É Þ ð ß ® ™ [Xurl=Xhttp://entmoot.tolkientrail.com/showthread.php?s=&postid=ABCXYZ#postABCXYZ]text[/Xurl] Splitting Threads is SUCH Hard Work!! |
12-19-2007, 05:24 PM | #129 | |
Elven Warrior
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 306
|
Quote:
As for the heat of the Ring, there do seem to be some inconsistencies. As far as this theory goes though, it isn't really important. What is important is that wearing the Ring was causing Isildur great pain, whether through burning or something else. When he put the Ring on, this tough, war hardened, king of the Numenoreans, cried out in pain. I don't think he would leave it on his finger any longer than necessary. |
|
12-19-2007, 06:41 PM | #130 | |
Lady of the Ulairi
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Minas Morgul
Posts: 2,783
|
Quote:
Val: I have read 2-3 pages (this thread is really soo... long) and I saw that I used to defend Elrond. Oh how young and naive I used to be 2 years ago... But seriously, I still don't think Elrond was in it by his own choice: likely he was compelled by his soon-to-be mother-in-law. They were likely all living in Rivendell at the time. Galadriel herself probably sent some trusted elves, and maybe even came herself. Unlike Elrond, she had no reason to pity Isildur. The other one I see there is Glorfindel. Maybe he was in charge. As for the moral side of it ... it would have been strange if the Elves did nothing at all to prevent Isildur becoming the next Dark Lord and their master. It would have been weakness on their part to sit and watch idly. I don't believe Isildur really had an intention to give the Ring to the keepers of the Three: he might have played with the thought, but actually give it away is another thing. |
|
12-19-2007, 07:07 PM | #131 | |
Elven Warrior
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 306
|
Quote:
|
|
12-20-2007, 07:31 AM | #132 |
Lady of the Ulairi
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Minas Morgul
Posts: 2,783
|
Then it would have happened by the East bank - and the Ring was found by the West Bank.
|
12-20-2007, 09:59 AM | #133 | |||
Elf Lord
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: LI-woods, NY
Posts: 653
|
Quote:
Quote:
Besides, to get on another side it’s not the matter of two boats, it is much more complicated task, since the river Anduin is very swift and running in a deep gorge. You can get to another side only by the bridge at the Cirith Forn en Andrath and at the Undeeps, south of Lorien’s border. Even to approach the sothern shore of Gladden field would be a problem, because the eastern side of the valley was very steep. But what it worth mentioning is that from the Gladden Fields to the realm of Lorien was stretching out the area of Silvan Elves' first settlement, which , no doubt, was controlled by Galadhrim. So it’s more likely to meet the elves over there than the orcs. Quote:
Among not interested also should be mentioned Umbar, Harad and Khand. They had a reason to worry about a military potential of two united kingdoms of the powerful Numenorians under the ruling of the Ring wielder. As a history has proved later , it was not unfounded worries: after conquering Harad , even without the help of Isildur with the Ring, Gondor’s dominion reached an enormous size, extending up to the sea of Rhun, and theopressed countries had to endure unbearable levies and humiliations from Gondor . So, they had the motives for Isildur’s elimination. They had potentials too. And also they have had an information, I wouldn’t consider them as stupid and ignorant to the growing treat. Then such unusual and fierece group of Commando-orcs could be just a troop of assassins- shahids, payed off by Umbar, Harad and ect. As for the Nazgul, I doubt they were the Nine. I was talking about the lesser wraith who might stayed nearby as an observers to make sure that the Ringbearer wouldn’t slip away in a wrong direction. Gordis is absolutely right, a self-preservance and protection of his oun country’s interests would be the most reasonable action of any ruler. Galadriel was a very smart politician and definitely wouldn’t ignore such obvious treat for a well-being of the Elves, so the archers were already waiting for Isildur. I also think that he just toyed with an idea to give the Ring to the Keepers, but it was up to the ring to choose the time to change the Keeper. My scenario is that Isildur saw who was waiting for him on the western shore and took out the Ring to put it on finger in order to hide himself from those who awaits him . But he did not even had a time to put it on the finger, the Ring already sensed that he is a "goner" and “had left his hand”. (UT) Near the shore he was being demanded to surrender the Ring, but upon realization that the Ring is gone, they just finished him. After that little incident the Lord of the United Kingdom would be too dangerous for Elve’s health even without the Ring .
__________________
Uruk-hai, or the journey to there. |
|||
12-20-2007, 10:56 AM | #134 | ||
Lady of the Ulairi
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Minas Morgul
Posts: 2,783
|
Quote:
What was not mentioned here yet, is that the East bank was largely controlled by Thranduil's Elves. Isildur was attacked on the path leading to Thranduil's city. But given the animosity between Thranduil and the ringbearers Galadriel and Elrond, I doubt that Thranduil was in the conspiracy. Had they given him a ring it would have been another matter... Quote:
|
||
12-20-2007, 06:19 PM | #135 |
The Chocoholic Sea Elf Administrator
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: N?n in Eilph (Belgium)
Posts: 14,363
|
Well, it is rather pointless in a way. The books says Elves and orcs don't like one another and that it was Orcs that shot Isildur, if others still prefer to say: no, the Elves were in league with the Orcs, or it was the Elves that done him in, then what can you argue?
__________________
We are not things. |
12-20-2007, 08:34 PM | #136 | |
Lady of the Ulairi
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Minas Morgul
Posts: 2,783
|
Quote:
But Elves were the most interested to do him in - any investigation will make them prime suspects. |
|
12-21-2007, 06:19 AM | #137 |
The Chocoholic Sea Elf Administrator
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: N?n in Eilph (Belgium)
Posts: 14,363
|
Perhaps not specifically in this thread, but it has been stated by our resident Elven Conspiracy theorists on previous occasions.
__________________
We are not things. |
12-22-2007, 01:07 AM | #138 | ||||||
Elf Lord
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: LI-woods, NY
Posts: 653
|
Quote:
Quote:
On another hand, why not Haradrim or Numenoreans from Umbar? Even without taking in consideration Isildur's ring, they had a good reason to be distressed by a prospect of a powerful ex-Numenorean kingdom as a next-door neighbor. Does not surprise you that the orcs, which in stature and power were less advantaged than the Numenoreans,who were usually "towering above the tallest Orcs", suddenly shown such resillience and mastery, that Dunedain of Numenor's origin couldn't overcome them, while Boromir of much lesser blood and endurance easily smote enemy 20 times outnumbered him? Doesn't it come to the mind that to get such defeat you have to fight not with midgets with short swords and spears, and with arrows, which can't penetrate the Numenorean armor, but with adversaries of the even status? Quote:
First of it, 2 000 is not 20, to feed such amount of eaters for 2 years won't be enough of chancy robberies. You need a steady supply of a different kind of provision, which they might get from Mordor or from Sauron's supporters. So, if the flow of provision has suddenly stopped, the first natural response would be to find out the cause of such hardship, and the second - to try to provide a supplement in some other way. As we know many of so called servants of Sauron after his defeat "became subject to the heirs of Elendil"(Sil.) at the same time keeping hatred towards the Dunedain's kingdoms, and very likely they would help to a stranded in the mountains small army of orcs. So, in both matters there is NO way that the Orcs have been totally unaware of what is going on, and the statement that they knew nothing doesn't hold the water. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
Uruk-hai, or the journey to there. Last edited by Olmer : 12-22-2007 at 05:59 PM. |
||||||
12-24-2007, 01:52 PM | #139 | ||
Elven Warrior
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 306
|
Quote:
To me, how Isildur's last moments played out is unanswerable, unless you wish to take the text at face value. There is very little evidence of what happened to Isildur after he fled. Considering that some of our evidence comes from our prime suspects, I would say all we have is: Isildur was killed (it doesn't have to be by arrows as his body wasn't found), the Ring ended up in the river (there are any number of ways this could have happened) and Isildur's sword & armor were separated from his body, ring case & crown (this could have been done by Isildur himself or his slayers, it is even possible that the ring case and crown were found separate from Isildur's body by Saruman). I wouldn't put much weight on what side of the river the Ring was found on as it could have been thrown (intentionally or unintentionally) or moved from one side of the river to the other by the water. Though I have argued that Isildur likely removed the Ring before his death (because I think it is what any reasonable person would do in the situation and it makes it easier to explain Isildur's killing if it didn't happen as the text says), I'll admit he could have been wearing it until the end. There is too little evidence to say for certain one way or the other. Quote:
However, if you look at these writings from a historical point of view, you have to wonder what was the Elves' plan (by Elves, I am mostly referring to Galadriel and Elrond)? Would they really sit idly by while a Numenorean king was once again corrupted by Sauron? The evil of Pharazon and its repercussions were fresh in their minds. Would they wait for the Valar to take action? Certainly Galadriel and Elrond knew better than to trust to such an unlikely event. Would they try to convince Isildur to give up the Ring willingly? But it would seem that this had already been attempted and attempted before the Ring had time to attach itself to Isildur's mind. Galadriel and Elrond knew he couldn't give up the Ring. They probably knew something about the fall of the Men who had become the Nazgul and certainly would remember that the Elves had failed to "find the strength" to destroy the rings themselves not too long before. I would say again that Isildur was probably showing signs of what evil was to come. He told his son on the battlefield before his death that he had tried to bend the Ring to his will. Would this go unnoticed by the holders of the three rings? Would Isildur's intentions be nothing but good? He couldn't be attempting to control Sauron, since Sauron was unbodied at this time. So, attempting to control the One would probably mean attempting to control the other ringbearers, the Ring's original purpose. Also, consider the scroll that Gandalf read. In it, Isildur says the Ring is precious to him. This word wasn't chosen by accident. Tolkien was trying to show that Isildur had already begun to succumb to the Ring. I am not saying that Galadriel and Elrond would have likely seen this document, rather I am arguing that the state of mind that would lead Isildur to call the Ring precious was probably made apparent to them in other ways. Ok, if we assume Isildur was killed just as it was written, what were the Elves' future plans concerning Isildur and the Ring? I don't think Tolkien told us, so perhaps one of our resident Elf defenders can give us a theory. |
||
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
How to take a Ring from an unwilling Ring-wielder? - crazy ideas | Gordis | Middle Earth | 217 | 10-03-2013 03:43 PM |
Ring's sentience and Ring detection | Gordis | Lord of the Rings Books | 17 | 01-04-2008 09:37 AM |
Calling All Nazgul : Formal Info Thread | The last sane person | RPG Forum | 37 | 07-20-2006 06:50 PM |
*Discussion Thread* Of Nazgûl-Kings-Friends-Rings Campaign (Calling all Nazgûl II) | Grey_Wolf | RPG Forum | 1000 | 10-04-2005 05:26 AM |
One Ring Ownership Legal Issue and my Response | patentcad | Middle Earth | 7 | 03-29-2005 04:01 PM |