10-08-2005, 09:23 PM | #21 | |||
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
The fact is that people are people. Many people claim to be a part of a religion, but they don't practice that religion in a true way. The Bible itself talks about people that pose as Christians but aren't. Paul describes people who come among his flock as "wolves among sheep." Jesus talked about those who would say, "did we not preach in the streets in your name," but who he never knew and who would be thrown into hell. There are Buddhists that aren't real Buddhists, Muslims that aren't real Muslims, Hindus that aren't real Hindus, and Christians that aren't real Christians. To organized church there is a wonderful side. There is a dark side to humanity, however. Philip Pullman says that the dark side is in the organized church. He does not say that the dark side is in humanity itself. In fact, while trouncing the church, he celebrates humanity. This is a very deep error. I think I can easily demonstrate just as hideous of wrongs taking place in non-denominational churches as happened in organized churches. Many cults and other groups that aren't responsible to a higher structure go off on tangents, try to control their participants, and fall into many kinds of errors. This is not about whether church is organized or not. It's about whether people will ever be truly good.
__________________
If the world has indeed, as I have said, been built of sorrow, it has been built by the hands of love, because in no other way could the soul of man, for whom the world was made, reach the full stature of its perfection. ~Oscar Wilde, written from prison Oscar Wilde's last words: "Either the wallpaper goes, or I do." Last edited by Lief Erikson : 10-08-2005 at 09:26 PM. |
|||
10-08-2005, 09:27 PM | #22 |
Fenway Ranger, Lord of Red Sox Nation
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: College!
Posts: 1,976
|
Maybe this is a little off-topic for a book thread, but yes, there were fanatic Christians during the Crusades. Just like there are radical Muslim suicide bombers. Both are, of course wrong. But the Crusades weren't totally murder, and they certainly weren't intended as murder.
__________________
Adventure...betrayal...heroism... Atharon: where heroes are born. My wife once said to me—when I'd been writing for ten or fifteen years—that I could always go back to being a nuclear engineer. And I said to her, 'Harriet, would you let someone who quit his job to go write fantasy anywhere near your nuclear reactor? I wouldn't!' (Robert Jordan) |
10-08-2005, 10:29 PM | #23 |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
I think that if we follow the discussion of that particular example's validity, we might really be leaving the topic of "His Dark Materials."
__________________
If the world has indeed, as I have said, been built of sorrow, it has been built by the hands of love, because in no other way could the soul of man, for whom the world was made, reach the full stature of its perfection. ~Oscar Wilde, written from prison Oscar Wilde's last words: "Either the wallpaper goes, or I do." |
10-09-2005, 04:28 PM | #24 |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: In me taters
Posts: 3,288
|
In response to your on-topic question Lief, I believe that it's one of the last passages in the trilogy where Lara learns to construct her own version of heaven.
|
10-19-2005, 12:12 AM | #25 |
Hobbit
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Neverland
Posts: 35
|
I think you have some valid things to say, Lief. And that I agree that the chruch has done some very wonderful things. But I also think that Pullmans main objective was the spiritual side of the things the Christians did. It's not a question that they have done some good and things and some bad, but there's no question of whether the church uses fear to "hijack individuals spirituality in order to control us" like the Gaffer put so well. And that is a terrible thing. People act as if all religions are like this, but it's not true. There are religions our there, like Buddhism, that doesn't try to convince you to adopt their beliefs (and kidnap your children when you don't). They would merely say that instead of trying to make someone like yourself, Buddhist, for instance, try to make them better at the practice they already practice. I think one point Pullman was trying to make is that SOME christians, perticulary those further up in the order, merely see spirituality as a way of controling the people, and not a quest for enlightenment. Pullman was pointing out that so much of the Church is about power and money, and will abuse the words of the Christ and people's belief in him in order to gain it.
Also, what you were saying about there being evil individuals makes sense, but does't hold much ground on the matter of these books. The whole point is that the church WAS one crazy individaul, God (or so he called himself), who did evil things through an oranization. So, in a way, Pullman agrees with you. Pullman's saying that your spiritaulity is something that you should not give complete control of over to someone who is human and has the potential for doing great evil. Last edited by Bran : 10-19-2005 at 12:13 AM. |
10-19-2005, 03:00 AM | #26 |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: In me taters
Posts: 3,288
|
Excellently put, sir or madam.
Historically, it seems as if the Church (like any other Organisation) has been corrupt in direct proportion to the amount of power it had. There is a strong element of caricature in Pullman's book, which I think he deliberately overplayed. The bottom line I took from HDM was that spirituality is an aspect of the human condition which we should embrace and take responsibility for as individuals and not hand over to others. The fact that it more or less accords with my own world-view probably biased my appreciation of the book somewhat, but it was certainly refreshing to see it reflected in a work of fiction, which is not something that I think I have come across before. |
10-20-2005, 06:49 PM | #27 | ||||||
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
Quote:
Quote:
The reason the Church's faults are so obvious is that the Church was so dominant, its influence so widespread, and its impact upon modern history so massive. Islam's faults are far more obvious. The Christians built empires that controlled people during the 1800s. The Christians fought bloody religious wars and also launched the Crusades, a hideous trail of atrocities. Islam, on the other hand, has been violent at pretty much every point since the religion's very beginning and continues in violence to this day. Remember the Ottomans? They only fell a century ago. Since then, Muslim states have frequently enacted violence in the name of Islam in the Middle East, against Israel. Muslim terrorist groups continue to do the same, but not only in the Middle East: around the world. Hinduism, supposedly also a religion of peace and tolerance, ruthlessly crushes opposition within its state. Remember the Hindu/Pakistani battles that Gandhi peacefully fought to overcome? Less commonly known are the modern time atrocities, such as the persecution of Christians, Buddhists and Muslims that Hindus practice in India to this day. People are fleeing out into hills and forests and India because Hindus steal or burn their homes, and attack them with beatings. Quote:
However, I agree with you that "SOME Christians, particularly those further up in the order, seek to control people." Except that I would add the letter 's' to the end of order, and would replace the word 'the' with the word 'some'. Though as regards organizations, it probably is all, I don't like generalizations . Quote:
Quote:
Even in times when parts of organizational churches were controlled by evil men, there was lots of good going on as well. Even when the pope was very badly flawed, there was lots of good going on as well. Christianity still maintained the heart and soul of culture and education. It continued many times (though not always) to support the needy and place beautiful moral doctrines in the hearts and minds of men. Quote:
I enjoy the discussion, Bran . Thanks for your intelligent and thoughtful (though in my opinion, flawed ) posts . I really do enjoy the discussion.
__________________
If the world has indeed, as I have said, been built of sorrow, it has been built by the hands of love, because in no other way could the soul of man, for whom the world was made, reach the full stature of its perfection. ~Oscar Wilde, written from prison Oscar Wilde's last words: "Either the wallpaper goes, or I do." Last edited by Lief Erikson : 10-20-2005 at 06:51 PM. |
||||||
10-20-2005, 10:51 PM | #28 |
Hobbit
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Neverland
Posts: 35
|
Thank you, Lief, I am also enjoying the conversation. I was just finishing up a lengthy post when my computer suddenly died on me and my writing was lost. I must have touched the power cord or something. I hate laptops...
I'll post a reply as soon as I can use my own computer. |
10-21-2005, 12:05 AM | #29 | |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
Quote:
__________________
If the world has indeed, as I have said, been built of sorrow, it has been built by the hands of love, because in no other way could the soul of man, for whom the world was made, reach the full stature of its perfection. ~Oscar Wilde, written from prison Oscar Wilde's last words: "Either the wallpaper goes, or I do." |
|
10-26-2005, 12:55 AM | #30 | |||||||||||
Hobbit
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Neverland
Posts: 35
|
Quote:
Oh, I agree that all religions have had their bad moments, and that most have had moments just as bad as the Christians. I don't mean to sound as if the Christian's were the only bad guys here, that's obviously a rediculous charge, and I'm sorry if I came off that way. I was merely stating that in certain instances, such as the tolerrance of other religions, there are and have been religions and governments who did a better job tolerating the beliefs of the people than the Church did. Quote:
It's true, but also did more damage because of it's widespread influence and dominance. Quote:
It's completely true, but the thing I think we need to realize is that Pullman isn't necesarrily saying Christians were worse than the Muslims, I think he ment to include all religions when he "attacked" the most obvious example of a large religion, Christianity. Quote:
I realize that the term "Enlightenment" is not used in the Christian tradition, I was using it as a generalization for the path or objective of a religious practice, which was too much of a generalization, I confess. But I'm not sure you fully understand the term "Enlightenment"m either. You make it sound as if the people who seek it search for it in books, when really it needent even be logical in the first place. "Enlightenment" is seen as a stillness within the chaos of life, and a feeling of wholeness and connectedness with all living things and with God. This is not the best describtion of "Enlightenment" or "Nirvana", but, to me at least, it doesn't sound all that different than what the Christians are practicing, though the words and terms used are different. Maybe you could comment on that? Quote:
Quote:
It's true that whatever religion he was trying to portray, he was showing one side of it's being. But, as I think I've said before, I think the purpose of the way he showed religion was not necesarrily to paint a perfect picture of Christian's or any religious group, but to show the characteristics of these groups that he wished were different. Quote:
I think that's true, and I think it was what Pullman was trying to say is that you should not give over something like your spirituality to something or someone wholey human and therefor has the potential for great evil. Like I have said above, I don't think it was Pullman's intent to paint a perfect picture of these organizations, and I doubt very much that if he had shown the Church doing much good, the book would have had as much of an effect on the reader. And even if he doesn't show the good, it doesn't mean there isn't any, and it doesn't mean the bad parts aren't true. I don't think that his leaving out of the good parts in any way undermines the truth of the bad parts. Quote:
Whether they liked it or not... Quote:
I believe this to be a very flawed argument, since the problem has most obviously not ceased to exist. The Church and religion has played a huge part in today's politics, and I hear from adults who have seen the years pass say that it looks even more influential to today's politics than it did twenty years ago. What about Bush claiming God told him to attack Iraq? That is an absurdly obvious religious influence in our government! My uncle left his Church after hearing the amount of pressure was being put on it's members to vote for Bush, and that has been a complaint throughout the country. I just read in the news the other of how Bush's reasoning behind trying to elect a new judge to the Supreme Court was based on the faith they shared. Which would upset the balance on the Abortion law trying to be passed equality of possitive vs. negative vote, effectively passing the law. If she does make it into the Court, then the law will be passed and religion will have played a part in passing a federal law! All this you call seperation of religion and politics? I say that's bull. Quote:
__________________
"If you will take my advice, you will think little of Socrates and a great deal more of truth". Socrates Last edited by Bran : 10-26-2005 at 02:10 AM. |
|||||||||||
10-26-2005, 01:55 AM | #31 |
Hobbit
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Neverland
Posts: 35
|
Extra note: The first thing the new (freaky-ass Nazi) Pope did when he came into power, as a way of "consolidating the empire", was completely condemn the practice of do-it-yourself religions, and told the people that that was a dangerous road and that when they tried to interpet Jesus and the Bible themselves, that they would become confused and stray from the right Path and head "down" the wrong one. His answer to this was for everyone to attend Church more and to only listen to what the priests told them. There's control for you. The newest Pope is well known to be nothing but a politician and has nothing but political ideas for his newly found power. Just thought I'd add that little bit.
__________________
"If you will take my advice, you will think little of Socrates and a great deal more of truth". Socrates Last edited by Bran : 10-26-2005 at 02:02 AM. |
10-26-2005, 02:48 AM | #32 | |||||||||||||
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I think a book that presents both what should be changed and what shouldn't would be painting a more accurate picture and would be presenting a more accurate message, by far. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
President Bush certainly has never gone on microphone to my knowledge and publicly said, "God told me to invade Iraq." Quote:
Quote:
I never heard that, though I'm not surprised that some people in the media would make the claim. What's the source, and was it a direct quotation? Quote:
As regards religion playing a part in passing law, I think it makes sense for them to be somewhat mingled. I think that people should pass laws in the way they think is right. By necessity, their religion or lack thereof will often impact how they view right and wrong. It also (whatever religion it may be) is central to the viewpoints of many voters. Religion must, to some extent, be meshed with politics.
__________________
If the world has indeed, as I have said, been built of sorrow, it has been built by the hands of love, because in no other way could the soul of man, for whom the world was made, reach the full stature of its perfection. ~Oscar Wilde, written from prison Oscar Wilde's last words: "Either the wallpaper goes, or I do." |
|||||||||||||
10-26-2005, 02:51 AM | #33 |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
One thing my history professor said about "Kingdom of Heaven", which stars Orlando Bloom, is that he had a high respect for the film until Orlando said in his speech that they would be acting for religious freedom. That, according to my professor, would have been considered absolutely absurd. It wouldn't have gotten him killed. It would have gotten him thrown in the insane asylum.
Just thought I'd mention .
__________________
If the world has indeed, as I have said, been built of sorrow, it has been built by the hands of love, because in no other way could the soul of man, for whom the world was made, reach the full stature of its perfection. ~Oscar Wilde, written from prison Oscar Wilde's last words: "Either the wallpaper goes, or I do." |
10-26-2005, 08:45 PM | #34 |
Hobbit
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Neverland
Posts: 35
|
William Monahan, the screenwriter of the film, did extensive research on the subject of his screenplay, and was quoting historical documents from the actual speech given from Bloom's character, who actually lived and did (most of) those things he did in the movie. I agree with your history teacher that in the time period, he would have been thrown in an asylum for saying such things, but knowing that he actually did say those things is what made the movie so powerful for me. And as much as I think I would respect your professor, I doubt he researched into that paticular subject as much as William Monahan did.
__________________
"If you will take my advice, you will think little of Socrates and a great deal more of truth". Socrates |
10-27-2005, 12:50 AM | #35 | |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
Quote:
__________________
If the world has indeed, as I have said, been built of sorrow, it has been built by the hands of love, because in no other way could the soul of man, for whom the world was made, reach the full stature of its perfection. ~Oscar Wilde, written from prison Oscar Wilde's last words: "Either the wallpaper goes, or I do." |
|
10-27-2005, 01:01 AM | #36 |
Honourary Elitist Inklette
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: between the mountains and the sea
Posts: 704
|
Y'know, of Phillip Pullman's writings, His Dark Materials is my least favourite. I guess it just seemed too heavy handed in the end, and really put me off. It had some really great parts to it, and he writes well enough, but the themes just didn't jive with me.
Clockwork, however, is a favourite book of mine. A little horrifying at times, yes, but so is Roald Dahl. |
10-27-2005, 04:32 AM | #37 |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: In me taters
Posts: 3,288
|
I've never read any of this other stuff; will look it out.
|
12-02-2005, 03:03 PM | #38 |
Elven Warrior
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: The Library, may it live forever!!!
Posts: 269
|
I love this series but i read them a bit out of order. I read The Subtle Knife first and that one remains my favorite one.
I think Embladyne is right in saying that they were a bit "heavy-handed" though I've never read any of Pullman's other works. The portrayal of Christianity and God was bit harsh and horrifying, really, to my young mind. I was 11. But it was a great series with a different feel to them than most children's books.
__________________
"Always forgive your enemies - nothing annoys them so much." ~Oscar Wilde "Don't tell lies you can't keep." ~My little sister... |
10-17-2007, 06:08 PM | #39 |
Halfelven Daughter of the Dunedain, President of Entmoot
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: In trouble. As usual.
Posts: 4,674
|
I think it's high time to wake this thread up. Almost two years is long enough for a nap. And I'm sure with the upcoming movie there is going to be a lot of re reads and first time reads and discussion.
Just so you know, I'm one of those first time readers. I started it today and I have to say just the first few pages have me hooked.
__________________
"Acaly und Hektor fur Presidants fur EntMut fur life!"~ inked Don't meddle in the affairs of Dragons, for you are crunchy and taste good with ketchup. "Don't be such a sour wolf" Stiles ~ Heart Monitor http://www.wattpad.com/user/IceQueenofMitera |
10-18-2007, 04:08 AM | #40 |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: In me taters
Posts: 3,288
|
Well, I'm jealous.
You have a fabulous journey ahead of you and I hope you enjoy it. I guarantee it will surprise you. |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
His Dark Materials Movies | GreyMouser | Entertainment Forum | 9 | 11-04-2007 06:11 AM |
The Tale of Arhdfaes Feedback | Black Numenorean | Writer's Workshop | 3 | 10-12-2007 10:04 PM |
The Dark Knight(Batman Begins sequel) | b.banner | Entertainment Forum | 13 | 02-26-2007 06:45 PM |
Join the Dark Side | Elanor | The Star Wars Saga | 167 | 12-19-2005 07:42 PM |
Why you believe what you believe I | Rían | General Messages | 1173 | 02-01-2005 03:56 PM |