11-19-2002, 12:55 AM | #201 |
The Insufferable
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 3,333
|
Quenya for numenor is 'Atalante'. I rest my case.
Now, let me give you a few examples of what allegory is and is not: The Pilgrims Progress is an allegory. The protagonist, Christian, represents christians on the road to heaven, 'the celestial city'. Paradise Lost is not an allegory. The protagonist, Adam, does not represent anybody else. He is literally the same Adam as in the bible. He travels through hell, which does not represent anything other than itself. The difference is not in the naming of things, but in the presentation, Aslan is Christ represented as a lion. Eru is God, represented as God.
__________________
Disgraced he may be, yet is not dethroned, and keeps the rags of lordship once he owned |
11-19-2002, 04:42 AM | #202 | ||
Elf Lord of the Grey Havens
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: somewhere else
Posts: 2,381
|
I found this quote in The Book of Lost Tales.
Quote:
Free will doesn't mean unconstrained. The creation of free will implies a priori existence of evil. In ME the variable of free will is constrained at times by the prophesies. Earendil's coming to Arda is fortold and his life is affected by the efforts of Ulmo to direct Tuor to Gondolin. All the events that lead to Earendil's subsequent birth and flight from Gondolin of Earendil must play out in a specific way for the final result to occur. Even though Tour warns Turgon of the councils of Ulmo he is ignored. Gondolin must fall so that Earendil can be brought to the sea after the flight from Gondolin. This begs the question as to whether Earendil would have come in some other way to his destiny. Is it the means we do not know or is the free will receding at times to the interference of the Ainur and Iluvatar. Another account in BoLT: Quote:
The fact that Melkor was a deity created without a corrupting influence indicates his curruption came from within. He manefested evil where none is shown to exist before. It must have been part of his creation and therefore it came from Iluvatar. Melkor did have may have had a choice but if the evil did not come from within then where?
__________________
There exists a limit to the force even ther most powerful may apply without destroying themselves. Judging this limit is the true artistry of government. Misuse of power is the fatal sin. The law cannot be a tool of vengance, never a hostage, nor a fortification against the martyrs it has created. You cannot threaten any individual and escape the consequences. -Muad'dib on Law The Stilgar Commentary |
||
11-19-2002, 04:51 PM | #203 |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
Cirdan, MasterMothra, the question you've raised about the contradiction between free will and Ilúvatar's future knowledge is one that RÃ*an and I have each given many, many posts explaining the answer to already in this thread. That's the only reason why we're reluctant to explain it again. Our previous posts on the subject are as good as anything we could do now. Perhaps neither of you were there during the earlier pages of this discussion?
However, to prevent you from having to look over all of those other pages, I'll give you another example of why having knowledge of a decision someone else will make doesn't mean that you made the decision yourself, and that they have no choice. If someone named Mike tells you that they're going to go to the bank, then you now know that they're going to do it. You know that they're going to go to the bank. The decision wasn't yours, but that doesn't alter your foreknowledge. Mike's decision was made, not yours. Thus you aren't making his mind up for him. People can change their minds about things; they can make whatever decision they want to make. Perhaps you know Mike really well though, so you know that he won't change his mind. So you know that he's going to go to the bank, and that he won't change his mind, but even though you know with a high degree of certainty what he's going to do, you still aren't making his mind up for him. With a god like Ilúvatar who has all knowledge, it's simply taking this one step further. I've been using human examples to make everything clear. Ilúvatar has foreknowledge, but as I demonstrated in my most recent example, that doesn't mean he's forcing you around. Just because Ilúvatar knows what someone will do doesn't mean he's making them do it. He could force everyone to do what he pleased, but that would destroy free will. But what I'm demonstrating is that he doesn't need to destroy free will to know what is going to happen. Now let's say you go up to someone named Becky. "Where's Mike going?" she asks. "He's going to the bank," you inform her. A prophesy has taken place (Although Silmarillion and Biblical prophesies are different from this because of the level and way of knowing, I think the example should demonstrate my point). You're not making Mike go to the bank, and Becky knows now what Mike is going to do. Her foreknowledge doesn't alter Mike's action, and neither does yours. Now let's say you know that going to the bank could be very bad for Mike. You know he's going to the bank (Like the prophesy of the fall of Gondolin), so perhaps you tell Becky to tell Mike not to go to the bank or something bad will happen. She goes and tells him. He's been forewarned about the future, and now he has a decision to make, whether to heed the warning or to ignore it. All of these things take place without anyone having any control over anyone else. Prophesies, future knowledge, all of these things aren't contradictory with free will. Last edited by Lief Erikson : 11-19-2002 at 05:05 PM. |
11-19-2002, 06:12 PM | #204 |
Elf Lord of the Grey Havens
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: somewhere else
Posts: 2,381
|
I did read all the thread last night. I was up with a sick kid. The question of causality and the creation event effects the excercise of free will. What part of the design of the creator is represented in the causal chain and how much is free will. Free will is a matter of degrees and few can make unfettered choices. My example from the Silmarillion regarding Earendil illustrates how the gods did intervene to achieve the desired result. The more active god is in the affairs of the beings in it's charge the less free will excercised. Inevitable choices only give the illusion of choice. Iluvatar is clearly stating that wheere his creation design leaves off (the outline) is where the free will is excercised. The intent is to create outside the design and that is the purpose of the free will of the Ainur. Melkor's ability to be evil is within the design of Iluvatar. Without an outside corrupting force Melkor originates evil. The ability to create evil is part of the design. Iluvatar either knows he is creating an evil being or not. If there is omniscience then there is benign evil in the creation of Melkor. The indication I see is that there are some events that are inevitable and some that are not. Iluvatar has a framework for operating within his creation. He also wants the inhabitants to create, to fill in the outline. Foreknowledge of this external creation as a result of design is intent. Melkor has no knowledge of punishment or consequence to his rebellious behavior because there is nothing stating this explicitly and he is not omniscient.
That's it for me for now. I'll be back after I get some sleep. zzzzzz
__________________
There exists a limit to the force even ther most powerful may apply without destroying themselves. Judging this limit is the true artistry of government. Misuse of power is the fatal sin. The law cannot be a tool of vengance, never a hostage, nor a fortification against the martyrs it has created. You cannot threaten any individual and escape the consequences. -Muad'dib on Law The Stilgar Commentary |
11-19-2002, 07:25 PM | #205 | |||
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
I actually think that your "framework and filling in" theory is incorrect. Ilúvatar's taking action doesn't destroy free will, and I have some examples of this.
Through Frodo, Ilúvatar brought down Sauron. Frodo's action was entirely free will, yet Ilúvatar had it planned way in advance, when Bilbo first found the Ring. Gandalf said that a higher authority meant him to have it, and that this same authority meant for Bilbo to find it. Because, as Wayfarer said, Ilúvatar can see all things and knows everything, he can plan in advance. He can use the smallest people for great things, and lift them up over impossible odds to do wonders. He waited for Earendil's simple act of obedience in coming back and asking for forgiveness for the Noldor and requesting help before he used the Valar to destroy Morgoth. He waited for the Valar to ask for his aid before he came to their defense and destroyed Ar-Pharazon's hosts. For example, if you know that Mike is going to the bank, you know you will soon have some money, so you can plan to go to the grocerie store when he gets back. In preparation, you get your things together and are ready to go when he returns. You didn't make him go to the bank, but you can do what you please in events because you know he is going to take this action. Ilúvatar can work through people and his will being done doesn't have to destroy free will at all. It can be an overall purpose, or design. He can raise up people who have complete free will, but whose free will is in accord with his design, to do his purposes. Free will isn't negated by his taking action. Quote:
What the passage says is that Ilúvatar has shown the person he's talking to what history's outline is. It doesn't say that he doesn't know what will happen in the smaller areas, or that he doesn't act in the smaller areas as well (Galadriel's providential gift to Sam of the box of dust and seed from Lothlorien could be taken as a kind blessing from Ilúvatar, as could other things). It simply says that he hasn't told the listener all of what will happen, it doesn't imply that he himself doesn't know, or that his design isn't visible in the smaller things either. Ilúvatar has related the outline of the greater events to the listener. He hasn't told the smaller things, but that doesn't mean he doesn't work with them and do things and know things. Free will isn't disturbed by close interaction of Ilúvatar with his works, and the passage you've given simply means that Ilúvatar has told the basic story (The abriged version, as it were) to the person he's speaking to. Maybe if I take the sentence and edit out the middle part of it for a moment you'll get a clearer sight of this: Quote:
Quote:
Last edited by Lief Erikson : 11-19-2002 at 07:33 PM. |
|||
11-19-2002, 07:39 PM | #206 | ||||
The Insufferable
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 3,333
|
Quote:
In fact, your entire line of argument restson a faulty assumption: That forknowledge and free will are mutually exclusive. There is really no reason to think that is the case. You seem to believe that forknowledge causes the events which it predicts, in which case it negates free will. However, it is far mor satisfactory to say that the events cause the forknowledge, in which case the two are compatable Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
In you example, Ulmo works to make one thing happen. Tuor works to make another thing happen. But it is Turgon who, in the excercise of free will, chooses what to do. It is both yes and no. Melkor did strip his minions of free will, but did Manwe or Ulmo? I don't believe you can show any evidence of them forcing thier will on anybody. In fact, you can look at examples like feanor, where it arguably would have been better for them to force him to do something different. The fact remains that each creature is made with a specific purpose. But they were also created with free will-including the ability to not carry out that purpose. The fact that some choose to excercise that option does not mean that they were not intended to carry out another purpose, any more than the fact that some choose not to excercise it means that they don't have free will. One last point: We can know what choices were made in the past. The fact that we know what choices were made does not negate the fact that they were choices. I do not view the future as any different from the past. It is simple we, from our vantage point in the present, cannot see it as clearly. But the fact is that whatever choices we're going to make, we're going to make them. In that sense the future is as pre-determined as the past. The question of free will is who does the deciding. Sleep well, my bearded freind. You're not going to get any rest on this issue. ]: )
__________________
Disgraced he may be, yet is not dethroned, and keeps the rags of lordship once he owned Last edited by Wayfarer : 11-19-2002 at 08:54 PM. |
||||
11-19-2002, 09:42 PM | #207 | |||
Half-Elven Princess of Rabbit Trails and Harp-Wielding Administrator (beware the Rubber Chicken of Doom!)
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Not where I want to be ...
Posts: 15,254
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
. I should be doing the laundry, but this is MUCH more fun! Ñá ë?* óú éä ïöü Öñ É Þ ð ß ® ç Ã¥ â„¢ æ ♪ ?* "How lovely are Thy dwelling places, O Lord of hosts! ... For a day in Thy courts is better than a thousand outside." (from Psalm 84) * * * God rocks! Entmoot : Veni, vidi, velcro - I came, I saw, I got hooked! Ego numquam pronunciare mendacium, sed ego sum homo indomitus! Run the earth and watch the sky ... Auta i lómë! Aurë entuluva! Last edited by RÃan : 11-19-2002 at 09:46 PM. |
|||
11-19-2002, 10:02 PM | #208 | ||||
Half-Elven Princess of Rabbit Trails and Harp-Wielding Administrator (beware the Rubber Chicken of Doom!)
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Not where I want to be ...
Posts: 15,254
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
. I should be doing the laundry, but this is MUCH more fun! Ñá ë?* óú éä ïöü Öñ É Þ ð ß ® ç Ã¥ â„¢ æ ♪ ?* "How lovely are Thy dwelling places, O Lord of hosts! ... For a day in Thy courts is better than a thousand outside." (from Psalm 84) * * * God rocks! Entmoot : Veni, vidi, velcro - I came, I saw, I got hooked! Ego numquam pronunciare mendacium, sed ego sum homo indomitus! Run the earth and watch the sky ... Auta i lómë! Aurë entuluva! |
||||
11-19-2002, 10:09 PM | #209 | |||
Half-Elven Princess of Rabbit Trails and Harp-Wielding Administrator (beware the Rubber Chicken of Doom!)
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Not where I want to be ...
Posts: 15,254
|
Quote:
Re Eru being God, Quote:
Quote:
__________________
. I should be doing the laundry, but this is MUCH more fun! Ñá ë?* óú éä ïöü Öñ É Þ ð ß ® ç Ã¥ â„¢ æ ♪ ?* "How lovely are Thy dwelling places, O Lord of hosts! ... For a day in Thy courts is better than a thousand outside." (from Psalm 84) * * * God rocks! Entmoot : Veni, vidi, velcro - I came, I saw, I got hooked! Ego numquam pronunciare mendacium, sed ego sum homo indomitus! Run the earth and watch the sky ... Auta i lómë! Aurë entuluva! |
|||
11-19-2002, 10:11 PM | #210 |
Elven Warrior
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: utumno and angband
Posts: 241
|
i cant break it down any simpler than that. if some one asks me if im irish i say yes........but im also scandinavian. but in the end i am truthfull in saying im irish.
what i meant by my child post is that your child post has as much relevance to the topic as mine did. im not putting god into any form, he is all powerful isnt he? he can forsee the future, and if we cannot change what is forseen then we have no "real" free will, just an illusion of it. all this is according to the christian belief that god is all powerful. the two cannot exist in the same dimension at the same time. that is why i dont believe that god exists, because, we have free will. same applies to tolkien in my opinion.
__________________
"........and his name is Melkor, Lord of All, Giver of Freedom, and he shall make you stronger than they."- sauron talking to ar pharazon. |
11-19-2002, 10:36 PM | #211 | |||
The Insufferable
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 3,333
|
Quote:
Quote:
God can know what choices are made in the future. The fact that he knows what choices will be made does not change the fact that we will have free will in the choosing. Your torturous logic doesn't stand. Even so, I forsee that you're going to keep repeating the same unsupported premise. ]: ) Now you have no choice in the matter! Hah! Quote:
If god exists, and he knows the future, then there is no such thing as free will. We have free will. So, God does not exist. Do you realize you base your conclusion on two unsupported premises? First, as has been pointed out, there is no reason to think that foresight and free will are incompatable. Second, you have no evidence that you do, in fact, have free will. After all, by your own logic melkor's rebellion against illuvatar was really illuvatar's plan,a nd even though he must have thought he had free will he really didn't. What stops you from applying the same logic to yourself? No, your argument doesn't hold water. In part, because you make the not-uncommon mistake of pretending your ideas about this God whom you profess not to believe in have more weight than those who do profess to believe in him. Free will has never been a problem for me.
__________________
Disgraced he may be, yet is not dethroned, and keeps the rags of lordship once he owned Last edited by Wayfarer : 11-19-2002 at 10:48 PM. |
|||
11-19-2002, 11:03 PM | #212 | |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
Quote:
Ilúvatar is the same. Both are the absolute creator. They created time, they don't abide by it. They never have to forsee. Before the beginning of the world (Either world ), God knew all of its history. It was a map laid out before him, and he gave people the free will to do as they chose. If it was forced to walk in his tune, sin would not exist and everyone would live in happiness. But no, he didn't force us. He had enough respect for his creations to create free will for them, so that they were themselves. With that came the possibility of evil, which he likewise knew would gain strength. He knew all and is all powerful, yet he permits us to make our own decisions. In Arda, people had the ability to do the right thing, and they had the ability not to. In Earth, people also can discern right from wrong (usually ), but here we get into Christian beliefs, such as original sin, Christ's coming to save the world, etc. So I won't get into that here and now. What did you think of the example I already offered, MasterMothra? What don't you understand about our explanations? If one human knows what another human is going to do, that doesn't mean they're manipulating, they're simply knowing. Why should it be different for God? |
|
11-19-2002, 11:10 PM | #213 | ||
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
Quote:
Quote:
Last edited by Lief Erikson : 11-20-2002 at 02:12 AM. |
||
11-19-2002, 11:58 PM | #214 |
Half-Elven Princess of Rabbit Trails and Harp-Wielding Administrator (beware the Rubber Chicken of Doom!)
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Not where I want to be ...
Posts: 15,254
|
(Lief, did you mean MasterMothra in your last paragraph?)
Well, MM, looks like you and I are at an impasse Oh well - I won't bother to repeat again what I've already said several times over. To me, free will and God's omniscience are perfectly logical and compatible. Apparently they aren't to you. C'est la vie! I hope you see the error in your logic soon!
__________________
. I should be doing the laundry, but this is MUCH more fun! Ñá ë?* óú éä ïöü Öñ É Þ ð ß ® ç Ã¥ â„¢ æ ♪ ?* "How lovely are Thy dwelling places, O Lord of hosts! ... For a day in Thy courts is better than a thousand outside." (from Psalm 84) * * * God rocks! Entmoot : Veni, vidi, velcro - I came, I saw, I got hooked! Ego numquam pronunciare mendacium, sed ego sum homo indomitus! Run the earth and watch the sky ... Auta i lómë! Aurë entuluva! |
11-20-2002, 12:18 AM | #215 |
Elven Warrior
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: utumno and angband
Posts: 241
|
"Your torturous logic doesn't stand. Even so, I forsee that you're going to keep repeating the same unsupported premise. ]: ) Now you have no choice in the matter! Hah"
well, i dont know what to say, umm....................thank you? what i appreciate about wayfarer is his willingness to respect others opinions, especially when they are not the same as his own. it is your gift in life i suppose. how old are you by the way?
__________________
"........and his name is Melkor, Lord of All, Giver of Freedom, and he shall make you stronger than they."- sauron talking to ar pharazon. |
11-20-2002, 12:25 AM | #216 | ||||||||
Elf Lord of the Grey Havens
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: somewhere else
Posts: 2,381
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
until tomorrow them
__________________
There exists a limit to the force even ther most powerful may apply without destroying themselves. Judging this limit is the true artistry of government. Misuse of power is the fatal sin. The law cannot be a tool of vengance, never a hostage, nor a fortification against the martyrs it has created. You cannot threaten any individual and escape the consequences. -Muad'dib on Law The Stilgar Commentary |
||||||||
11-20-2002, 12:29 AM | #217 |
Head Hollara
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Texas
Posts: 751
|
Hey, I learned something cool in church Sunday (how often does that happen? Soooo kidding)...
Obviously, if God is omniscient as well as omnipotent, he must know what we will do as beings on the Earth. So, why bother at all? Our teachers' explanation: Basically, we believe we chose to come here and live our lives as God would have us (i.e.; the ten commandments). He knows where we will end up after death and all, but we need to prove it to ourselves. How lame would it be if He just sorted us and told us where we belong without any kind of test? Obviously, we would have to accept it, He being omnipotent and all, but He is just. Assigning our destiny without any measure would be not-so-just. It is better to watch a movie yourself than to just be informed of the ending, isn't it?
__________________
"People used to ring up and say 'Don't quit your day job' or 'sell your synth', but the joke's on them: we were fired and the synth is broken!" -John Flansburgh from They Might Be Giants Ever heard of Mormons? I'm one. Click here to know more about us. |
11-20-2002, 02:11 AM | #218 | ||
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
Ilúvatar's nature
Cirdan, what I really don't get is how you can simply restate the same opinions as you gave before, ignoring all of the examples and explanations that we've given on these subjects. We have shown in numerous examples from real life and the Tolkien books that free will can coexist with foreknowledge. You haven't given any reason why it can't, you've simply said it can't.
But rather than restating my examples and the reasons for them again, I will simply go on to the two parts of your posts that we haven't already responded to as thoroughly. Quote:
Quote:
When he was created, he was created with a free will. This made him capable of evil, right from the start. However, as he was created by God, his nature was originally good. He was created powerful, very powerful, and this was one of the factors that led to his undoing. Morgoth knew that he was greater than the other Valar, and this led to pride. Yet he couldn't create by himself, he could only alter, and he was second only to Ilúvatar. He became envious of Ilúvatar. Pride and envy certainly aren't the greatest sins, but they were the first ones that led to others. He grew to want to strike out on his own and gain more power for himself. Ilúvatar stood in his way to complete dominancy, and he was arrogant enough to think he was up to the match, so he rebelled. Other Maiar obviously also thought that he had a good chance of success, otherwise they wouldn't have joined in his revolt. This is what I think happened, and I think that pride and envy were also Satan's downfall, for he also was created originally good. As for whether or not Morgoth was purposely created evil . . . if you accept that point of view, then you're calling Ilúvatar a liar, a hypocrite, and a tyrant. He strikes out many times against evil, to protect and uphold the righteous. If he purposely is dabbling in it himself, by causing it or creating it, then he is a hypocrite. He also is a tyrant to the good peoples that he claims to uphold, for bringing upon them evil. He also is a liar for pretending to be good. I think that there are strong enough evidences against this point of view in the books to disqualify the idea that Ilúvatar created Melkor evil. |
||
11-20-2002, 02:14 AM | #219 | |
Elf Lord
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Fountain Valley, CA
Posts: 6,343
|
Quote:
Last edited by Lief Erikson : 11-20-2002 at 02:15 AM. |
|
11-20-2002, 02:19 AM | #220 | |
Half-Elven Princess of Rabbit Trails and Harp-Wielding Administrator (beware the Rubber Chicken of Doom!)
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Not where I want to be ...
Posts: 15,254
|
And here comes RÃ*an with ... you guessed it! ... ANOTHER quote from The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien (and if you hang around on Entmoot long enough, you won't need to buy the book, because I'll have quoted the whole thing!
Quote:
__________________
. I should be doing the laundry, but this is MUCH more fun! Ñá ë?* óú éä ïöü Öñ É Þ ð ß ® ç Ã¥ â„¢ æ ♪ ?* "How lovely are Thy dwelling places, O Lord of hosts! ... For a day in Thy courts is better than a thousand outside." (from Psalm 84) * * * God rocks! Entmoot : Veni, vidi, velcro - I came, I saw, I got hooked! Ego numquam pronunciare mendacium, sed ego sum homo indomitus! Run the earth and watch the sky ... Auta i lómë! Aurë entuluva! |
|
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
The Silmarillion:Ainulindalë | Maedhros | The Silmarillion Project | 96 | 08-21-2018 12:49 PM |
Demaethor and Amariel | Rosie Gamgee | Writer's Workshop | 14 | 11-13-2007 09:05 PM |
I made a song!!!!! part II | StrawberryIcecream | Lord of the Rings Books | 313 | 05-01-2006 09:43 AM |
Is bringing the Elves to Valinor wrong? | Beren3000 | The Silmarillion | 51 | 12-01-2004 04:25 PM |
The nature of Prophecy in Middle-earth | bmilder | Lord of the Rings Books | 23 | 06-16-2000 04:10 AM |