Shadowfax is IN

[bropous]

oh come on, jerseydevil we know you send fan letters to Peter Jackson and have a little shrine at home to which you pay homage in his name and that you're waiting breathlessly for the DVD to come out so you can play the Arwen bits over and over again..... (just kidding! )

I don't think that the Scouring in the film would have had to play out what Frodo saw in Galadriel's mirror. Remember that he saw what COULD have happened, not necessarily what was GOING to happen.

samwise of the shire, that long line of letters means: "Extremely insightful and deeply reflective individuals of rare character and quality who share a deep and abiding knowledge of literary masterworks of extreme detail and delightful creativity, without whom the incredible works of a tremendously talented Oxford professor would fade into obscurity".....it's an answer I gave a while back to a thread on "what are tolkien fans called?".....

[Earenya]

Personally, I was highly disappointed that Gandalf is shown in the spoiler pictures (and I've heard in TTT trailer as well). Some people had no idea that he survived and I hate the idea of that being ruined.... my only consolation is that his appearance is very different.

Shadowfax definately is needed in the film. And I thought that the scouring of the shire should be in as well- isnt that part of the point? That evil can return to what you love best, to home? And that (men) can no longer count on the protection of wizards and elves??