Free Will

[Coffeehouse]

Originally Posted by crodgers148

I was wondering if I could possibly get some help (thoughts, specifics, etc.) on a thesis I am working on. The prompt in which I am writing a paper on (rather short, at 2-3 pages) is the following:
"Gandalf, Elrond, and Aragorn have all insisted that their followers undertake dangerous missions only of their own free will. They will not compel anyone. By contrast, Sauron and Saruman corrupt, break, or distort the free will of their followers.

Evaluate the importance of free will as a defining characteristic of free people. Use specific examples from the story to illustrate each point you make."

I would appreciate any help that you could give: but what I am looking for, mainly, is direct instances within the Return of the King. Thank you for your help and I can't wait to discuss your responses!

Interesting questions. That made me think of the why Saurons allies were his allies in the first place, and why they chose to commit so heavily. Is it because Sauron forced them? Or do beings that commit evil in Lord of the Rings have little or no free will?

Why and when do men rebel? Are the decisions made through a free will, and if so, on what basis? Do you go to arms on the basis of a need (i.e. the need to protect yourself, your family, your ideology?), on the basis of greed (i.e. is there some economic gain to be drawn from becoming a rebel, or an insurgent, a warrior?) or is based on grievance (you feel an injustice, an inequality, inferiority)?

Perhaps Sauron didn't force all of his 'allies'. Perhaps he instead made them aware of an opportunity that allowed for a decent situation as to account for their needs, greeds and grievances. Rationally, and on the basis of a free will.