Hobbit movie plot ideas

[Mark of Cenla]

Originally Posted by Curufin

Ah, now I don't even have to say it.



Er...this sounds pretty much from the movie, not from the book. Do you have any textual evidence for this? Because this certainly isn't the feeling I got.

We are talking about the movies here. So it seems to me that whatever the new movies do has to be more consistent to the existing movies than the books.

I had to let go of the movies closely following the book a long time ago. If I hadn't, I would still be pissed off about the ending in Return of the King. To each his/her own.