Red Collector's Volume of LotR question

Greetings everyone!

A year or two ago I read a review of the red, single volume, leatherette collector's edition of the Lord of the Rings. In this review it was mentioned that several years had very good printings and others, very poor ones. I haven't been able to find that review again, and I was wondering if anyone out there happens to know which are good years to search for as far as paper and printing quality goes.

Thank you kindly!

dnvechoes@yahoo.com