arwen aragorn elrond and galdriel

Ã‘Ã³lendil · 12-16-2001, 06:33 PM

He remarried with a Vanya, dunderhead!

There was a huge debate among the Valar about that though. Marriage is supposed to be binding, and MÃ*riel was supposed to return among the Living, death being an unnatural thing for the Eldar. So really FinwÃ« was allowed to remarry because MÃ*riel refused to return, right?

Many of the Elves who died before the Great Journey or many of the Avari are said to have remained in Mandos, having no desire to live again. So Imin and IminyÃ« may have lived together in Mandos until the end of Time, it's possible.

12-16-2001, 06:33 PM	#21
Ã‘Ã³lendil Elf Lord Join Date: Jan 2001 Location: California Posts: 60,865	He remarried with a Vanya, dunderhead! There was a huge debate among the Valar about that though. Marriage is supposed to be binding, and MÃriel was supposed to return among the Living, death being an unnatural thing for the Eldar. So really FinwÃ« was allowed to remarry because MÃriel refused to return, right? Many of the Elves who died before the Great Journey or many of the Avari are said to have remained in Mandos, having no desire to live again. So Imin and IminyÃ« may have lived together in Mandos until the end of Time, it's possible. __________________ Falmon -- Dylan