LOTR = Typical Action Films?

[thranduil]

Originally posted by jerseydevil
[B]I'm saying the gift giving scene doesn't matter as an overall plot element for the average movie goer since it was not included in the theatrical release. You can not say - well it was included in the extended edition - or jackson will fix it in the extended edition. The scene should have been in the theatrical release - that is my complaint. Most people do not know where Sam got the rope or anything without having seen the extended edition.

B]

Let me ask you one question Jersey Devil. What average movie goer who hasn't read the books gives a whoot where Sam got the rope. The only scene I even have seen a rope is around gollum. A very short scene, in which the audience assumes Sam packed some rope.

But speaking of ropes. I'm excited to see the repelling scene in E.E.
Even if it wasn't in the theaters.