we must be graterful for peter jackson

[Entlover]

Samwise, I totally agree, you've hit the nail on the head as usual.
However, clearly perceptions differ depending on a multitude of factors.
I don't think M Faramir can be described as loathsome and greedy when he let them go in the end -- I wonder if I'd have the courage to do that in the same circumstances.

Perhaps this discussion should be continued when more information is available -- the EE of TT and RotK.